Help Jambioers

Since everyone on here seems to be realistic in their own way, I need help. I'm stuck in a rut and I only have three days. I have to choose between two amazing guys and i feel like im on the freaking bachelor. Boy one, Sky. We've been good friends for about two years and he's liked me for six. He used to be someone i hated, but we were family friends. Somehow, we developed an inseperable friendship last year but he pined over me all summer. I didn't want a relationship, and ended up "leaving him" in August for someone i had a 7 month relationship with. After we broke up, he was there even though we had had a tumultuous relationship while he was away at school. We became really close again, all of a sudden. Of course, it was obvious he quickly developed feelings for me again. Boy 2, Olivier. We became casual friends last summer. We'd talk until like 4 am online, but never developed feelings. We literally weren't friends all year. In mid-April i saw him at a local restaurant and he started texting me. He, Sky, my friend, and i all went to eat and to a movie shortly thereafter. Of course sky had to make a scene and temporarily ditch us. The night went well overall and Olivier and I made photobooth pictures. They are now hidden behind my mirror in my car. We started talking more and more and obviously we developed feelings for each other. Sky is always there though, like my comfortable jeans. He knows everything about me. I know that he will be in love with me forever, but i don't think i'm in love with him. Olivier is kinda new and he's very refreshing. He's very relaxed and i love it. Sky obviously reads me like a book (oh and i swear on my life Olivier must be a freaking mind reader because he always knows what i'm thinking). Sky pretty much figured out i liked olivier and so he's making me pick between us on June 11. It was June 2 but i got him to extend it. I have no idea what to do. If i pick Sky, I "can't" see Olivier for a month and we have to talk less. If i pick olivier, I cannot talk to Sky at all and there will never be another chance. To make matters more difficult, I had the idea to just tell Olivier we could just be friends for the time-being, meaning i could still be friends with the both. Then tonight, he calls, and he's not your typical dating type, he's very chill. He told me he thought all day and that we should date because he thinks it would be really good and workout. He said he really liked talking to me and conversation actually flowed unlike with other girls. Also, Sky's outta town so i cant see him again before the decision. Oh, and i adore this song, where is that doubledecker bus when i need it. But then again, that'd raise a question of, "who would make it such a 'heavenly' way to die?' Help Jamsbioers!